Search results for ‘Subject term:"mental health problems"’ Sort:
Results 1 - 2 of 2
Internal vs. external care management in severe mental illness: randomized controlled trial and qualitative study
- Authors:
- RUTTER Deborah, et al
- Journal article citation:
- Journal of Mental Health, 13(5), October 2004, pp.453-466.
- Publisher:
- Taylor and Francis
- Place of publication:
- London
Case management is the encompassing model for managing people with severe mental illness, but models of case management vary. The aim was to compare the effectiveness of an integrated (internal) model of care management (in which the social worker is a member of the multidisciplinary healthcare team) against a brokerage model in which the care manager operates "externally" to the healthcare team. Patients with severe mental illness meeting a high threshold of need referred to a community team were randomized to a care manager newly appointed to the team, or to a care manager outside the team. Days spent in hospital were the primary outcome measure, and costs for patients in each arm were compared. Semi-structured qualitative interviews were employed to explore a sample of cases in each category; compare joint working practice in both models; and compare practice in London to that within a well-established integrated CMHT in Nottingham. The randomized trial of "internal" vs. "external" care management showed no significant differences in outcome or costs among 26 patients. However, the qualitative study revealed worker dissatisfaction with the brokerage model, and identified inefficiencies and duplication of effort. The brokerage model of case management should not be maintained.
Beyond the boundaries
- Authors:
- RUTTER Deborah, WASSELL Julia
- Journal article citation:
- Community Care, 4.2.99, 1999, p.22.
- Publisher:
- Reed Business Information
A placement where student nurses and social workers collaborated may point the way to the future of community care. The authors explain how it worked in practice in Hillingdon.